Strategic Start-up Partnerships for Industry…

Navigating Challenges in Germany’s SME Landscape

The German medium-sized business landscape is facing a series of challenges that have increased in complexity and urgency in recent years. Skilled labour shortage, the protection of sensitive IT infrastructures, weak economic development, and increasing competitive pressure pose major challenges for companies - and are often difficult to overcome alone. ¹

In response to this upheaval, collaboration with start-ups has emerged as a promising strategy for medium-sized businesses. Start-ups bring more than just innovative ideas and technologies; they also bring the agility and flexibility that can sometimes be lacking in larger, more established companies. Partnering with start-ups allows businesses to harness this dynamism and address their most pressing challenges.

This page explores the current state and possibilities of companies teaming up with start-ups, particularly in Germany and Europe. In an era where technological advancements like AI and the Metaverse are pushing boundaries like never before, the role of start-ups as trailblazers of tech has never been more crucial. We'll cover different partnership formats, talk about the pros and cons of each, and throw in some real-life success stories.

However, navigating these partnerships isn't always smooth sailing. We'll also discuss the common hurdles that can arise in these collaborations and provide insights on overcoming them. Our goal is to equip you with the knowledge and tools needed to leverage the innovative potential of start-ups and future-proof your business.

Pressing Industry Challenges in 2024

Technological Leap & Adaption

Skilled Labour Shortage

Efficiency and Digital Transformation

Rising Costs and Supply Chain Disruptions

Presented by

These insights are collected and presented by UnternehmerTUM - the leading center for innovation and business creation in Europe with over 20 years of experience in the development of innovation strategies and the implementation of technology-driven business ideas.

180+

Corporate Innovation Partnerships/ Year

12,000+

Participants /Year

50+

Scalable Start-ups /Year

Forum UnternehmerTUM 2024 - an annual invite-only event for changemakers and international visionaries sparks action for a liveable future

Prof. Dr. Helmut Schönenberger (CEO, UnternehmerTUM) and Dr Robert Habeck, Federal Minister for Economic Affairs and Climate Action

Ultimate Demo Day, powered by various UnternehmerTUM subbrands and partners, provides a platform to connect with the most promising cutting-edge start-ups right now

20240228 Tech Founders Casino Night 8532

UnternehmerTUM Corporates & Investors Casino Night brings together the forward-thinkers and decision-makers shaping the future of innovation, fostering meaningful connections and exchange

Our events feature a diverse lineup of speakers: Jonas Deichmann, a German adventurer and record-breaking extreme athlete, captured at the Ultimate Demo Day 2022

How Start-up-Collaborations Address Technological Leaps

In the age of constant change and technological advancements, the term "Outside-In Innovation" is increasingly becoming a buzzword for companies seeking fresh approaches to stay competitive and continue to evolve. Outside-in innovation refers to the approach of using external knowledge, capabilities, and skills to initiate and accelerate internal innovation processes. Statistics reveal, that on average, firms direct 70% of their innovation budget to core enhancements, 20% to adjacent innovation, and 10% to disruptive projects.¹¹

Start-ups play a central role as a source of novel ideas, agile working methods, and disruptive technologies. In certain industries, collaboration is seen as a crucial form of staying in the game: in the aerospace industry, 100% of corporates have already collaborated with start-ups.⁷

Start-ups are not just shaking things up; they are practically leading the charge. Take the burgeoning metaverse ecosystem as an example: With 1,385 emerging metaverse start-ups identified in 2023, including major players like Meta, Qualcomm, and Microsoft actively investing in metaverse technologies, there's a real anticipation for the potential transformative impact of virtual worlds.²

Despite the term “metaverse” itself losing its shine in the past year (Apple’s product announcement for Vision Pro didn’t use terms “metaverse” even once), same innovation area keeps its interest with new terms such as “spatial computing” and "three-dimensional user interface". ³ ⁶

AI infrastructure research and governance 1

The desire to explore unknown business opportunities ranks as the foremost objective driving corporates to engage with start-ups. Sustainability, Artificial Intelligence, and Cybersecurity are the top three areas corporates aim to explore in collaboration with start-ups.⁷

AI and Big Data alone accounted for nearly a third of global VC-funded start-up deals in 2022, underscoring the critical role of these technologies in transforming industries and unlocking new market opportunities.¹⁷

Over in the DACH region, start-ups are making waves, especially in AI; Generative AI start-ups in the region have seen a surge in funding, surpassing previous records, while overall VC funding levels have returned to pre-2021 levels.⁴

In 2023 alone, a total of 341 AI-related start-ups were founded, corresponding to a rise of 67% compared to the previous year.¹⁶ The number of German unicorns has shot up (quadrupled in the last five years) - but there's still some catching up to do with the big guns like Israel and the USA.⁵

Number of newly funded AI start-ups 2013-2023 ¹⁵

5,509

United States

1,446

China

727

United Kingdom

442

Israel

397

Canada

391

France

338

India

333

Japan

319

Germany

193

Singapor

189

South-Korea

147

Australia

Collaboration Is the Norm, Not the Exception

Corporate-Start-up collaborations in Europe have gained remarkable traction: approximately 72% of European corporates are actively engaged in projects with start-ups, and a substantial two-thirds of these companies deem such collaborations important or critical for their strategic objectives, underscoring the significance of start-ups in driving growth within established companies. Having a dedicated department or business unit handling these partnerships makes a big impact; nearly 90% of companies that consistently meet their objectives have one set up for this purpose.⁷

The timing of the launch of these collaborations reflects the increased emphasis on open innovation as a response to global challenges: about 50% of the Corporate-Start-up collaborations analysed in The Open Innovation Report were launched during or after the pandemic. The efficiency of these collaborations has notably improved as well. Previously, 75% of Corporate-Start-up partnerships took an average of at least seven months to reach the go-live stage - today, only 42% of the projects take that long.⁸ This shift not only demonstrates the increasing agility of corporate and start-up teams but also their growing capability to swiftly turn ideas into actionable outcomes.

+70%

European corporates are actively engaged in projects with start-ups

89%

of Successful Corporate-Start-up Collaborations were managed via dedicated department or business unit

External Support and Programs Boost Collaboration Success

Getting outside help can significantly enhance the success of collaborations between bigger companies and start-ups. About 55% of corporates use third-party intermediaries to manage their open innovation projects, and this involvement has been reported to greatly boost their project success.⁷ More than three-quarters of the Fortune 100 are active in the venture capital (VC) space, with half having a VC arm set up as a subsidiary, not including companies with internal VC business units.¹⁰ Most new ideas and innovation projects originate from idea competitions and intrapreneurship programs, with only around 25% of ideas coming from the management team.¹¹

Let's Recap: Benefits of Corporate-Start-up Collaboration

Established companies can benefit from the latest technological advancements they might not otherwise have access to, and explore new markets and business models, without having to develop them in-house. This approach saves valuable time and resources, positioning these companies at the forefront of innovation and ensuring their competitiveness.
Start-ups bring not only specific expertise and technological know-how but also an entrepreneurial mindset and innovative strength that established companies often struggle to replicate.

The Blueprint of a Successful Collaboration

Successful collaboration between SMEs and start-ups requires a clear structure and a strategic approach. Here are three key principles to establish a rock-solid foundation for a powerful and effective partnership.

Management Commitment and Establishment of KPIs

Management commitment and support are crucial to the success of a collaboration with start-ups. It is important that management recognizes the importance of these partnerships and is actively committed to them. This can take the form of financial support, provision of resources and the setting of clear goals and key performance indicators (KPIs). By setting KPIs, the progress and success of the collaboration can be measured and evaluated, enabling continuous improvement.

Understanding the own Company as a Service Provider for the Start-up

To create a win-win situation, SMEs should view their company as a service provider for the start-up. This means that they don’t only provide a budget, but also make their expertise, experience and resources available. This can help start-ups to implement their ideas more quickly and accelerate their growth. It is also important to make clear agreements and contracts about the collaboration to define and document the expectations of both sides.

Supporting Consciousness within the Company about the Collaboration

Companies must foster awareness and acceptance across all levels. This involves proactive communication about collaboration goals, engaging relevant business units from the outset, and ensuring that employees understand how the partnership impacts their work environment. Additionally, SMEs should avoid exclusivity with a single start-up and remain open to diverse partnerships for a broader range of ideas and innovations.

How we've connected the dots in Germany and beyond

„So können wir nicht weitermachen“

Der Bundeswirtschaftsminister will bis zu 15 Start-up-Factories fördern. Dafür gibt es ein Vorbild – das von Helmut Schönenberger geleitete Gründungszentrum UnternehmerTUM.

How Do Different Corporate-Start-up Collaboration Formats Compare?

Various collaboration formats between established companies and start-ups serve as vehicles for innovation. The primary collaboration formats include innovation and digital labs, accelerators, corporate venture capital (CVC) units, partner units, and incubators. Successful corporates continually refine these formats, for example by transforming existing incubator units into CVC units. ⁹

Here's a Snapshot of the Six Most Common Collaboration Formats

Third-Party Accelerator Program or Incubator: Access a diverse pool of coached start-ups without directly managing the program

A program run by an external organization that helps early-stage start-ups accelerate their growth by providing them with mentorship, expert coaching, connections and opportunities to pitch to investors, and sometimes funding.

Key Benefits:

• Access to a diverse range of well-coached start-ups without bearing the operational burden of managing the program

• Potential investment opportunities and equity stakes in promising start-ups.

Best Suitable for:

• Small to mid-sized companies looking to access innovations without the heavy resource commitment required for running an in-house program

Possible Risks or Challenges:

• Limited control over the program's focus

• Limitations of the selection of the start-ups depend on the program
Corporate Accelerator Program or Incubator: Drive specific innovation aligned with your business goals while actively shaping the start-up’s growth

Corporate Accelerator Program or Incubator is an initiative by a company to support and mentor internal or external startups, providing them with resources, mentorship, and opportunities for pilot projects to develop innovative products, services, or business models aligned with the company's strategic goals.

Key Benefits:

• Direct influence over the selection of the start-ups and over the program structure and the start-ups' development, ensuring alignment with corporate strategy

• Enhanced ability to integrate start-ups' innovations into the corporation's existing processes and products

Best Suitable for:

• Corporates with resources to invest in long-term innovation projects and can integrate new technologies at scale within their extensive operations

Possible Risks or Challenges:

• Significant investment of time, resources, and management attention

• Balancing internal bureaucracy with start-up agility
Corporate Venturing: Strategically invest in start-ups for financial returns and access to innovative technologies

Through Corporate Venturing larger companies invest directly, through joint ventures or equity stakes, in external start-ups that align with their strategic goals to gain insights into emerging trends and access to innovative technologies.

Key Benefits:

• Possibility for high financial returns and competitive advantages

• Early access to cutting-edge technologies and business models and building relationships with the ecosystem and talent

Best Suitable for:

• Larger companies with financial resources to invest in start-ups

Possible Risks or Challenges:

• Requires venture capital expertise and carries financial risk if the start-up fails

• Potential conflicts of interest and may not align with short- or medium-term goals, especially during economic downturns
Open Innovation Challenge: Encourage creative solutions from external start-ups to address specific problems or gaps

Innovation Challenge is a competition where a company or organization seeks innovative solutions to specific problems by inviting startups, entrepreneurs, and external innovators to participate. Winners may receive funding, partnerships, or opportunities to pilot their solutions with the sponsoring organization.

Key Benefits:

• Cost-effective way to source a large number of innovative solutions and ideas for a specific challenge

• Enhances the corporation's reputation as an innovator and thought leader and increases brand awareness through contact with a broad audience

Best Suitable for:

• Companies of varying sizes looking for diverse solutions for a specific challenge

Possible Risks or Challenges:

• Ensuring actionable outcomes from the challenge to further develop ideas after the challenge

• Mitigating intellectual property risks ensuring proper attribution and rights to the solutions

• Potential conflicts of interest and may not align with short- or medium-term goals, especially during economic downturns

• Managing a large volume of submissions can be resource-intensive
Pilot Projects and Proof-of-Concepts (PoCs): Validate the start-up’s technology or concept before committing to a larger-scale implementation

A pilot project or proof of concept (PoC) serves as a small-scale test between a company and a startup to develop and test new products, services, or technologies, often leading to broader collaboration if successful

Key Benefits:

• Offers a cost-effective means to assess the solution's feasibility prior to full-scale deployment, providing valuable insights to inform decision-making and mitigate risk

• Start-ups' agility and dynamism facilitate rapid advancement in product prototype development and deployment

Best Suitable for:

• Companies ready to test specific solutions with a start-up

Possible Risks or Challenges:

• Potential for pilot projects to fail, leading to wasted resources. Stability is not guaranteed due to start-ups’ risk aversion and acceptance of uncertainties

• Limited scope may not adequately anticipate future challenges or facilitate scaling to full implementation
Venture Clienting: Become an early adopter or client of a startup’s product

Venture Clienting is a model where companies act as early customers for start-ups' products or services. By gaining early access to cutting-edge technologies and solutions, they enhance their competitive edge within the industry. Simultaneously, they provide crucial feedback and validation to the start-up, allowing them to focus on product development aligned with market demand, thereby minimizing the time and resources required to acquire initial customers

Key Benefits:

• Companies can customize the start-up's solution to meet their specific requirements, ensuring better alignment with existing processes and systems

• Faster time-to-market compared to internal R&D initiatives

Best Suitable for:

• Medium to large companies seeking direct value from start-up products without equity involvement

Possible Risks or Challenges:

• Balancing risk tolerance with start-up experimentation while navigating potential mismatches between start-up capabilities and corporate expectations

• Integrating and supporting start-up solutions within the corporate environment demands substantial effort.

3 Corporate-Start-up Success Stories

Partnerships and collaboration projects between established companies and global start-ups have catalyzed the creation of innovative products, enhanced customer experiences, and optimized quality control processes. Take a look at some of the examples from our ecosystem:

HP Tech Ventures & Simplifyber: Introducing The First-Ever Biodegradable Plant-Based Shoe

The collaboration tested a new process for developing textiles, incorporating HP's technology, resulting in the development of the world’s first fully biodegradable plant-based shoe.

WACKER & ANTICIPATE: Enhanced Quality Control With AI-Powered Video Analytics

Implementation of the start-up's solution in WACKER's plant promises improved and technology-based detection capabilities for foreign objects, ensuring higher recognition accuracy.

ADAC & VirtualQ: Over 300,000 Saved Waiting Minutes In Less Than Six Months

The implementation of intelligent callback management during a proof-of-concept project reduced waiting times by over 300,000 minutes and significantly boosted customer satisfaction.

Unraveling the Causes of Partnership Failures

Lagging Enthusiasm in Germany - Has Berlin’s hype worn out?

Despite the growing number of Corporate-Start-up collaborations across Europe, significant challenges persist, particularly in Germany. While countries like Italy and the Benelux region exhibit the highest enthusiasm for open innovation (with 80% of the companies actively pursuing these initiatives), Germany lags behind with only 57% participation in such partnerships.⁷ This is notably low considering Berlin’s reputation as a leading European start-up hub. Collaboration between start-ups and established companies has fallen by 10 percentage points in the last three years and now stands at 61%. Only 28% of start-ups report satisfaction with corporate partnerships.¹² Corporate venture capital is also more restrained than in the previous year.⁵

So what is hindering Corporate-Start-up collaborations?

Despite 79% of companies ranking innovation as a top-three priority, only 6% of executives are satisfied with their innovation performance. Additionally, dissatisfaction with existing partnerships is a critical issue, with 45% of corporates and 55% of start-ups reporting being “very dissatisfied” or “somewhat dissatisfied” with their collaborative efforts.⁹ These results underscore the pressing need for the development of more effective innovation strategies and collaboration formats.

1. Lack of Clarity and Expectations

Corporate-Start-up collaborations often face challenges due to unclear objectives and unrealistic expectations. Companies may expect tailored solutions without considering start-up capabilities or implementation efforts. Meanwhile, start-ups prioritize access to the larger partner’s market. To succeed, a holistic approach that recognizes both sides’ needs is crucial.

2. Lack of Corporate Support

Only a few collaborations make it to fruition; just over 11% of Corporate-Start-up collaborations make it all the way to scaled deployment. These “would-be” collaborations are hampered along the way not only on the start-up side of the equation but also through a lack of corporate support. Only 37% of start-up respondents say that corporates have dedicated resources, budget, or a well-defined scaling process to drive start-up collaborations. ⁸

3. Legal & Regulatory Barriers

Legal and regulatory issues account for 14% of the incompatibility challenges between corporates and start-ups, creating significant hurdles that can stifle potential partnerships and innovative breakthroughs.⁷

4. Low Risk Tolerance & Legal Barriers

13.7% of companies cited the low risk tolerance as a reason for incompatibility with start-ups.⁷ Corporates often hesitate to embrace projects due to a reluctance to adopt uncertain or unconventional innovations, despite potential rewards. Evaluating financial and market risks against possible benefits can hinder their willingness to invest in and test new products or solutions. Additionally, sharing information with start-ups poses risks to proprietary knowledge, leading to potential intellectual property issues.

5. Prolonged Time to Go-Live

A critical issue emerges from the prolonged time required for collaborations to reach the go-live stage in Europe compared to other regions. This delay hampers the ability of both corporates and start-ups to swiftly capitalize on innovative opportunities, reducing the competitive edge that these collaborations are intended to provide.⁸

Achieving Corporate-Start-up Success: A Six-Step Guide

As we have seen throughout this page, these collaborations provide mutual benefits - start-ups obtain access to resources and market expertise, while corporations benefit from new ideas, agility, and technological advancements. However, while the potential benefits are significant, a number of obstacles can impede the success of these collaborations.

To ensure your company is equipped to overcome common challenges, we've compiled steps and a checklist for successful collaboration between your company and start-ups, maximizing the benefits for both parties. As mentioned above, leveraging third-party services which specialize in facilitating such collaborations, has been proven to enhance partnership outcomes. Consider using third-party accelerator or incubator programs, Corporate-Start-up matchmakers, or venture client partners to streamline your collaboration process.

For further information on how your start-up partnerships can be elevated or how to begin leveraging collaboration with start-ups to enhance your company's competitiveness, please contact our designated personnel listed at the end of this page.

Roadmap to Successful Collaboration Projects

Champagne and Black Simple Modern Design Thiking Process Information Graph 3200 x 1400 px 1

Checklist for Thriving Corporate-Start-up Partnerships

✓ Set expectations & clear objectives early on

✓ Align a detailed roadmap at the beginning

✓ Clarify the type and scope of support you can provide

✓ Get access to the data you need from the start

✓ Clarify NDA and other legal matters

✓ Be honest and transparent about the budget and plan early

✓ Involve decision-makers in the process from day 1

✓ Clarify the tasks/duties of both parties

✓ Encourage a transparent and open dialogue

✓ Specify internal marketing promoter for the start-up

Turn these insights into impact: Contact Our Experts

Let’s Talk Innovation Strategy

UnternehmerTUM Business Creators combines methodological expertise with strategic implementation to drive innovation projects. Guided by business design principles, we leverage our extensive experience in problem identification and solution development to ensure long-term competitiveness

What we offer:

Align corporate and innovation strategy and identify fields of innovation
Discover customer needs and technologies and develop business ideas
Validate new business models and implement them on the market
Activate the core organization and empower innovators within the company

Let’s Talk Start-up Collaboration

TechFounders specializes in strategic partnerships between corporates and start-ups through various matchmaking formats. We prioritize addressing the unique needs of each corporate and start-up, focusing on maximizing the effectiveness of their collaboration.

What we offer:

Venture Clienting: Establish your in-house venture client unit or transform other innovation unit formats into a venture client unit
Pilot Project Program (Partnership): Low-risk validating the feasibility and potential impact of a start-up's solution without the need to operate your own in-house program.
Start-up Scouting for various purposes, including your own innovation challenges, with insights into the latest innovation market trends.

250+

Completed Innovation Projects

180+

Fostered Pilot Projects or POCs between Corporates and Start-ups