Key Topics

“Regulation Should Not Hurt Innovation” – Interview with Françoise Soulié-Fogelman about Europe’s Position in AI

UTUM Colab2021 727web © Copyright: Thomas Dashuber
01 June 2022
Applied Artificial Intelligence (AI)

Dr. Françoise Soulié-Fogelman is Scientific Advisor at Hub France AI, Co-chair Innovation & Commercialization Working Group at GPAI and specialist in data mining and big data. With her international expertise not only as founder of a company and head of the Data Science team at the School of Computer Software at Tianjin University in China, Soulié-Fogelman could give us a comprehensive insight into Europe’s position in Artificial Intelligence.

What is the current state of artificial intelligence in Europe?

In the work at the AI High level Expert Group[1], four enablers for successful deployment of AI in Europe were identified: Data and Infrastructure for AI (develop open-source AI software libraries and data management and sharing initiatives), Generating appropriate Skills and Education for AI (redesign education systems, develop and retain talent and upskill and reskill the current workforce), Establishing an appropriate governance and regulatory framework (ensure appropriate policy-making based on a risk-based and multi-stakeholder approach, and establish governance mechanisms for a Single Market for Trustworthy AI in Europe), Raising Funding and Investment (address the investment challenges of the market and enable an open and lucrative climate of investment). The European Commission have since acted on these different enablers, in particular by pushing a very significant regulation and financing agenda.

Where are the strengths of Europe concerning AI technologies?

Europe has many strong points: a very well-educated population, with good scientists and engineers (this reflects in Europe’s first rank in terms of publication level); a good education system with well-established AI programs, a strong segment of B2B companies, which represent 2/3 of AI-created value2, and a vibrant community of AI start-ups[2] with 106 new creations in 2021 compared to 119 in China and 299 in the US.

Many European companies still have not adopted AI, especially among SMEs.

Françoise Soulié-Fogelman

Which barriers do companies in Europe face adopting AI?

Many European companies still have not adopted AI, especially among SMEs, yet the number of those considering AI is growing. The main barrier is always the fragmented European market, which has many consequences: difficulty to access or share datasets, in particular for “European” topics (for example speech recognition data sets for French) difficulty for start-ups to secure sufficient investments and scaleup, difficulty for talent to find enough high-level jobs and for companies to offer high enough salaries compared to those GAFA routinely proposes in European locations; difficulty for SMEs to identify trusted partners to help them embark on their AI transformation; difficulty to find sovereign solutions made-in-Europe for sensitive applications.

What could politics, economy and society do about it?

We need regulation for AI so that the European society trusts AI is fair and beneficial. However, regulation should not hurt innovation and negatively impact the economy. The coordinated Plan on AI and AI Act[3] proposed by the European Commission still have to be enacted: the impact on European economy will be very significant. We need to follow-up carefully how it is implemented to make sure that AI indeed serves for the good of European citizens.

How do we secure a human-centered use of AI, fair and free of bias?

Europe is very active in producing regulation to ensure that AI deployed in Europe is trustworthy. The topic of trustworthy AI is generating lots of interest and activities among European companies, with many questions discussed, among which that of making ethics recommendations operational while preserving innovation certainly is top on companies’ agenda.

Thank you very much for the Interview!

Image Francoise Soulie klein weiss eingerueckt schmal

Further information provided by Françoise Soulié-Fogelman:

The last AI Index from Stanford[4] shows an increase in all indicators measuring the global activity in AI worldwide (from 2020 to 2021): AI Journal Publications (+13%), AI Patent Applications (+69%), Total AI Private Investment (+101% to $B 90.83), legislative records on AI (from 1 in 2016 to 18 in 2021 in 25 countries) etc. while cost for training AI system and training time decrease (for example -63.6% for cost and -94.4% for time in image classification since 2018 with best systems achieving better than human performance, for example, 99,02% Top-5 accuracy of an AI system on the ImageNet classification challenge compared to the 94,90% human baseline). However, when comparing these indicators between US, China and Europe, the respective situations appear very different: for example, if Europe maintains a strong publication level with respect to the US (19,05% of total world journal publications for Europe to 13,67% for the US), they’re both distanced by China (31,04%); Europe is completely left behind the US and China for AI patent applications (3,89%, 16,92% and 51,69%) and for total AI Private Investment (6,42%, 52,87% and 17,21%). Also, most pre-trained AI models come from the US (for example the best ImageNet classifier is from Microsoft or language model GPT-3 from Open AI) as well as most GitHub libraries (TensorFlow has the most cumulated number of GitHub stars 160,70 k, compared to scikit-learn originally from France which comes 5th with 48k).





Related Stories

AI Impact Survey Titelbild 3

Threat to innovation? A survey among European start-ups on the EU AI Act

AAI Whitepaper Mockup Culture

Mastering the AI Culture Change in Organizations — Video Interview with Dr. Philipp Hartmann, Director of AI Strategy at appliedAI

Fokusthemen KI Kompetenz Titelbild neu

Successful with Artificial Intelligence - Free Online Course On AI Competence for your SME

Badge Copyright Julian Beekmann Fotografie 4 © Copyright: Julian Beekmann Fotografie

"Now we can't let ourselves be left behind" - Interview with Jonas Andrulis on Artificial Intelligence in Europe.

Vanessa Cann 2 kl copyright Tobias Koch BADGE

“Europe is on the threshold of digital policy dependency” - Impulse by Vanessa Cann, Managing Director of KI Bundesverband

Zukunftszentrum067 © Copyright: appliedAI

Free Training on AI and Digitization for SMEs: Zukunftszentrum Süd

Applied AI MAT 2021

Maturity Assessment - The Free Tool to Assess Your AI Maturity Level

KI Campus 2

Discovering the Potential of AI: New Online Course "Introducing AI" on the KI-Campus

AI final

Making SMEs fit for AI: „KI-Transfer Plus" model project by appliedAI and the Bavarian State Ministry for Digital Affairs

2021 startup landscape banner

Fourth Annual Landscape by appliedAI: German AI Start-ups Convince with Quality

AI Illustration Batch3 Farbvariante green DE 2

Artificial Intelligence in Business and Economy - Free Online Course by appliedAI

Hartmann Philipp 600x400

"AI is Always Just a Tool" - Interview with Philipp Hartmann, Director of AI Strategy at appliedAI

News applied ai philipp gerbert

How Corona Crisis is Affecting Artificial Intelligence in Europe - 5 Questions to ... Dr. Philipp Gerbert from appliedAI

Applied AI

Artificial Intelligence - the Key to Intelligent Business of the Future?


AI Start-ups in Germany: Landscape of 2020 by appliedAI


"Elements of AI": appliedAI Supervises Education Platform for Artificial Intelligence


62% more AI Start-ups in Germany


Appell an die Bundesregierung: appliedAI-Initiative fordert Mut und rasches Handeln in ihrem Positionspapier

stories-applied-ai-initiative-partner © UnternehmerTUM / Bert Willer

UnternehmerTUM presents appliedAI initiative

stories-Accelerating-adoption-of-ai-andreas-liebl © UnternerhmerTUM / Bert Willer

Accelerating the adoption of Artificial Intelligence